Every songwriter knows the moment. You are at a showcase, a session or an after-party, and someone with real reach is standing right there. Do you hand over your demo?

Usually you should. But three lawsuits in the news this fall are a reminder that if the song you shared ever turns up on someone else’s record, what you did before you shared it can decide whether you have a strong claim, a weak one or one that is hard to pursue at all.

Three demo cases in three weeks

On November 11, 2026, Universal Music and Warner Chappell told a federal court in Los Angeles that they had reached a settlement in principle with Louisiana rapper Lamount London, known as L.Mont. His suit, filed in September 2024, claims he handed Quavo a demo CD of his song “Bubblegum” at a Migos after-party in New Orleans in 2016, and that Quavo’s 2018 track “Bubble Gum” copied it. The terms were not disclosed, and the notice did not say whether the deal resolves the claims against Quavo personally.

Two other demo cases ended quickly. On October 27, a Portland songwriter withdrew his suit claiming Drake’s “Janice STFU” copied a chorus he had sent to producers in Drake’s circle; Drake’s side had denied the claims and accused him of altering file metadata. On November 4, three songwriters dropped their suit alleging that BTS’s “SWIM” copied a demo they say was passed to one of its credited writers through a publisher. Both dismissals were voluntary and without prejudice, and no court ruled on whether any copying happened.

What a copying claim has to prove

To win a copyright infringement case, you generally must show that you own a valid copyright and that the other side copied protected parts of your work. Copying is usually proved with two things: access (a reasonable chance they heard your song) and similarity (the songs share enough original, protectable expression).

That is why each of these complaints told a story about how the demo traveled: a CD handed over at a party, files sent to producers, a demo shared through a publisher. Access is often the hardest piece to prove, and the strongest evidence is usually the evidence you create at the time you share.

Why registration timing matters so much

You own the copyright in your song the moment it is fixed in a recording or on paper. But for a U.S. work, the Copyright Act generally requires registration (or a refusal from the Copyright Office) before you can file an infringement suit.

Timing matters even more for money. Under Section 412 of the Copyright Act, statutory damages and attorney’s fees are generally unavailable if the infringement of an unpublished work began before it was registered. Statutory damages run from $750 to $30,000 per work, up to $150,000 for willful infringement, without proving exactly what you lost. Without them, you may be limited to proving your actual damages or the infringer’s profits, and paying your own lawyers.

The good news: the Copyright Office’s Group Registration for Unpublished Works option lets you register up to ten unpublished works for a single fee, if the group meets its eligibility rules. Copyright Office fees are also going up, which is another reason to file now.

Practical steps before you share a demo

  1. Register first. Register your strongest unpublished songs before they leave your hands, grouping them where you can to keep the cost down.
  2. Keep a clean paper trail. Send demos by email or a tracked file link instead of only handing over a drive or CD, and save the message, date and recipient.
  3. Save your work files. Keep original session files, voice memos and lyric drafts with their dates, and do not edit file metadata after the fact.
  4. Get splits in writing. If you wrote with others, sign a split sheet so everyone’s ownership is clear before the song circulates.
  5. Read submission terms. Some companies require you to sign a submission agreement before they will listen. Know what rights you are giving up.
  6. Act promptly. Copyright claims generally must be brought within three years, so do not sit on a concern.

If you think your song was taken

Hearing something familiar on the radio does not mean it was copied. Songs share common chord progressions, rhythms and phrases, and those building blocks are not owned by anyone. Before you go public, gather your registration, dated files and records of who received the demo, and have a lawyer (and often a musicologist) compare the works. As these cases show, a lawsuit filed without strong evidence of access can end almost as quickly as it began.

Whether you are a writer protecting a new catalog or a publisher or artist facing a claim, the team at Shrum Disney & Associates on Music Row is glad to talk through your situation. Reach out to us or call 615.338.5130.

Related on Law on the Row

Further reading

This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, contact Shrum Disney & Associates or call 615.338.5130.

If you have a stack of songs, masters or catalog paperwork that you have been meaning to file with the U.S. Copyright Office “one of these days,” this is the month to do it. The Office has asked Congress to approve a new fee schedule, and under the copyright statute those fees can take effect once a 120-day review period runs out. The Office submitted the schedule on July 14, 2026, so that window closes around November 11. After that, many of the filings Music Row relies on will cost noticeably more.

Here is what is changing, why registration matters in the first place, and how to get your filings in while the current fees still apply.

What the Proposed New Fees Look Like

According to the Copyright Office’s Proposed Schedule and Analysis of Copyright Fees to Go into Effect in Fall 2026, several everyday filings for songwriters, artists and publishers are set to go up:

  • Single Application (one work, one author, filed online): from $45 to $55.
  • Standard Application (filed online): from $65 to $85. On paper, from $125 to $185.
  • Group registration for works on an album (GRAM): from $65 to $85 for musical works, and from $65 to $130 for sound recordings.
  • Group of unpublished works (filed online): from $85 to $130.
  • Recording a document such as an assignment or a publishing agreement (online base fee): from $95 to $215.
  • Recording a notice of termination on paper (Form TCS): from $125 to $275.

The Office’s analysis also describes raising the special handling (expedited) surcharge from $800 to $1,100. Congress can block the new schedule only by passing a law disapproving it, so unless that happens the Office may put these fees in place as early as mid-November.

Why Registration Is Worth the Fee

Your song is protected by copyright the moment it is written down or recorded. So why register at all? Because registration is what gives that protection teeth:

  • You generally cannot sue without it. For U.S. works, the Copyright Act requires that the Copyright Office act on your application before you file an infringement lawsuit. The Supreme Court confirmed in 2019 that a pending application is not enough, and processing can take months.
  • Statutory damages and attorney’s fees depend on timing. Under Section 412 of the Copyright Act, those remedies are generally available only if the work was registered before the infringement began, or within three months of first publication. Without them, many infringement cases are too expensive to pursue.
  • It builds a public record. A registration made within five years of publication is evidence of ownership, which helps when you license a song, sell a catalog or settle a credit dispute.

Don’t Forget Chain-of-Title Paperwork

The largest proposed jump hits recordation, which more than doubles. Recording assignments, co-publishing deals and catalog purchase documents with the Copyright Office puts the world on notice of who owns what. It can also protect a buyer if the same rights are later transferred to someone else. If you bought or sold songs this year, or have older transfers that were never recorded, it may make sense to file them now.

A Note for Songwriters Planning Terminations

Songwriters and their heirs can sometimes take back rights they granted decades ago through the Copyright Act’s termination provisions. A notice of termination must be recorded with the Copyright Office, and the paper filing fee is proposed to more than double. Terminations run on strict statutory deadlines, so cost should never be the reason to delay one. Still, if a notice is ready, there is no reason to pay more for it.

Practical Steps Before the Deadline

  1. Inventory your unregistered works. List the songs, recordings and lyrics you have released or plan to release, and check which are already registered in the Copyright Office’s online public records.
  2. Group what you can. GRAM and the unpublished-works group option let you cover up to 10 or 20 works in one application, which can cut your cost per song.
  3. Confirm who owns what. Co-written songs need accurate authorship and ownership information. A signed split sheet makes this much easier.
  4. Record your transfers. Gather any assignments, administration agreements or catalog purchase documents that should be on file.
  5. File online and early. Online filing costs less than paper. To get today’s fees, make sure your complete application, deposit and payment are submitted well before the new schedule takes effect.

We Can Help You Get It Filed

Registration forms look simple, but small mistakes, such as listing the wrong claimant, mixing up the musical work and the sound recording, or grouping works that don’t qualify, can cause problems later. If you would like help organizing a catalog, preparing registrations or recording transfer documents before the new fees arrive, we would be glad to talk with you.

Related on Law on the Row

Further reading

This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, contact Shrum Disney & Associates or call 615.338.5130.

Editor’s Note: In November 2017, this blog started a series asking whether intellectual property law still mattered in a “high speed digital age.” My intern at the time, Lucas Evans, wrote the opening piece, and it holds up remarkably well. It called artificial intelligence a coming force in the economy before most of Music Row had heard of it. Nine years later, AI is here. Below is my follow-up, which takes up the questions we’ve been working through on the Gavel Drop.

In 2017 we asked whether intellectual property law was still relevant. In 2026 the question has turned around: whether the people who make things will get to keep what they make.

The 2017 article had two reasons why IP law mattered: the internet was everywhere, and “artificially intelligent machines” were coming into the workplace. It predicted that as machines took over routine work, “the value we bring to the workplace and to the world will increasingly be defined by our capacity to be creative.”

That part was right. The part nobody saw coming was that the machines wouldn’t just take the routine work. They would take the creative work too, trained on the very songs, books and lyrics that human beings spent their lives writing.

Where We Got It Half Right

The original article told the story of a 1600s settler building a cabin in the colonial woods. It asked what makes the cabin his. Then it said this:

“And it’s not some natural law that protects the cabin. In the absence of government, nothing would prevent a gang of bandits from killing him and taking it.”

A few paragraphs later it quoted John Locke’s Second Treatise of Government: “every man has a property in his own person,” and “the labour of his body, and the work of his hands, we may say, are properly his.”

I want to pull those two ideas apart, because the whole AI fight sits in the gap between them.

The bandits can take the cabin. That’s true. But the fact that someone can take a thing has never told us whether it was theirs to take. Locke’s point was not that government creates property. His point was the opposite. When a person mixes her labor with the world and brings out something that didn’t exist before, it is hers by right, and the law’s job is to recognize that right. The law doesn’t create it. The bandits don’t own the cabin. They just have it.

That distinction mattered in 2017. In 2026 it is the whole case.

Copyright’s Two Souls

As I’ve said on the Gavel Drop, American copyright has two souls living in one body, and they have never fully made peace.

The first soul is in the Constitution. Article I, Section 8, Clause 8 gives Congress the power “to promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts” by securing to authors, “for limited Times,” the exclusive right to their writings. On that view, copyright is a bargain. Society grants a temporary monopoly because it encourages people to create. This is Jefferson’s soul. In his 1813 letter to Isaac McPherson, which the 2017 article quoted at length, he said ideas spread “like fire” and that society “may or may not” grant exclusive rights “according to the will and convenience of the society.”

The second soul is older than the Constitution. It runs back through Blackstone and Locke, and it says the author’s right doesn’t begin with the government’s grant. A song is the fruit of a writer’s labor the same way the harvest is the fruit of the farmer’s. This is closer to Madison’s soul. He wrote that a man “has a property in his opinions and the free communication of them.”

Here’s why that matters now. The artificial intelligence industry has built its whole defense on the first soul, and it would very much like you to forget the second.

Listen to the arguments. Progress. Innovation. The greater good. Information wants to be free. The old rules were built for a slower world. And besides, you can find those lyrics anywhere on the internet. Every one of those is a utilitarian argument. Each one asks you to weigh the songwriter’s claim against some larger social benefit and find the songwriter wanting.

The natural-law tradition answers all of them in five words: It was not yours to take.

It doesn’t matter how impressive the machine is or how transformative the output is. It doesn’t matter that the lyrics are “freely available” either. Lyric websites pay for the right to display those lyrics. Publicly accessible has never meant publicly owned. The natural-law question isn’t about consequences. It’s about consent. Was the work taken, or was it given?

The Courts Are Finding the Second Soul

What strikes me about the past eighteen months is that the courts keep coming back to that older principle, even when they use the language of the newer one.

The book decision. In Bartz v. Anthropic (N.D. Cal. 2025), Judge William Alsup was generous to the AI side on training. He found that using books to teach a model was transformative. But he drew a bright line at how the copies were obtained. Downloading millions of books from pirate libraries was not fair use. It was, in the court’s words, “straightforward piracy.” The case then settled for roughly $1.5 billion. Whether the court would put it this way or not, that is a natural-law distinction dressed in fair-use doctrine: you cannot build even a useful thing on a foundation of theft.

The memory of a machine. In November 2025, the Regional Court of Munich ruled for GEMA, Germany’s collecting society, against OpenAI. It held that memorizing song lyrics into a model’s parameters is a reproduction, and that it is “irrelevant” that the lyrics exist only as probability values. That decision is first-instance and not binding here, but two legal systems on two continents are reaching for the same intuition: the memory of a machine is not a loophole.

The songbook goes to court. In August 2026, Sony Music Publishing and Warner Chappell sued Anthropic in San Jose over song lyrics. Canada’s SOCAN has sued Suno in Toronto, calling it an unlicensed streaming service. And the major labels are still fighting Suno in Boston. You can hear the second soul in those pleadings. When the publishers write that songwriters “depend on this compensation to earn a living,” that’s Locke. When SOCAN says creators “were never asked, never informed, and never given the chance to say no,” that isn’t the language of a licensing dispute. It’s the language of a taking.

And the license that looks like a confession. When Suno retired its old models and launched a new one trained on licensed music from Warner, BMG and Believe, it proved the point. For two years the industry said asking permission was impossible. Then one of them asked, paid, and shipped a product. Consent is no longer a philosophical position. It’s a working market.

The Principle Cuts Both Ways

This is the part I didn’t fully appreciate until we worked through it on a recent episode.

The same Lockean principle that makes unlicensed training a taking also explains why a purely machine-made song belongs to nobody. Copyright is the law’s way of recognizing human labor. Where a human labored, the law protects the result. Where no human did, there’s nothing to protect.

The law has landed in the same place. The Copyright Office’s 2025 report on copyrightability says prompts alone aren’t enough human authorship. In March 2026, the Supreme Court declined to hear Thaler v. Perlmutter, which leaves standing the rule that a machine cannot be an author. What you write, what you compose and what you genuinely select and arrange is yours. What the machine generates from your prompt is, on current law, no one’s.

That’s not a loophole. It’s the law doing what Locke said it should: recognizing a person’s labor and refusing to invent a right where no person labored. The AI industry wants it both ways. It argues that training doesn’t need the human author’s consent, and then argues that the output should carry a human author’s rights. So far, the law isn’t giving it both.

The Honest Counterpoint

In fairness, there is a serious case on the other side. Jefferson wasn’t wrong that ideas are non-rivalrous, and the 2017 article was right to take him seriously. Copyright has never protected ideas, styles or genres, only expression, and it shouldn’t start now. Many scholars argue that training on lawfully acquired works is closer to reading than copying. Bartz itself agreed on that point. Others argue the Copyright Office’s line on AI-assisted works under-protects people who put real creative judgment into iterating with these tools. Cases like Allen v. Perlmutter may move that line. And other countries, including the U.K. and China, have taken different approaches to computer-generated works.

Those are real arguments, and the courts will spend years on them. But none of them answers the threshold question of consent. Where a work was pirated, scraped past a license, or memorized and handed back on request, the utilitarian case is answering a question nobody asked.

What This Means on Music Row

For the writers, artists, producers and publishers we represent, here is the practical version:

  • Provenance is everything. Chain of title has always mattered on Music Row. Now it matters for the machines too. Ask any AI tool you use what it trained on and whether it was licensed.
  • Keep your human authorship visible. Write your own lyrics and top lines. Save your sessions, stems and dated versions. When you register, disclose the AI material and claim what’s yours.
  • Negotiate AI on purpose. Training rights, output rights and voice/likeness rights are now separate line items in publishing, label and producer agreements. Here in Tennessee, the ELVIS Act adds voice and likeness protection on top of copyright.
  • Know your PRO. Look at who’s winning these cases: GEMA, SOCAN, the publishers. Collectives with organized catalogs. Make sure your works are registered and your splits are filed.

Back to the Cabin

In 2017 we said it wasn’t natural law that protected the settler’s cabin. It was government. I’d put it differently today. Government is what enforces the right. Natural law is why there’s a right to enforce. The bandits could always take the cabin. The question has always been whether anyone should pretend it was theirs.

A song is that settler’s cabin. The writer cleared the land, cut the boards and built something out of nothing but talent and labor and the ache to say something true. Machines can now take it apart and rebuild it in seconds. That doesn’t change whose it is.

Is intellectual property law relevant in the age of AI? It has never been more relevant. And John Locke has never been more right.

Barry Neil Shrum is an entertainment attorney with Shrum & Associates, PC (Shrum Disney & Associates) in Nashville and teaches music industry contracts and copyright at Belmont University’s Curb College of Entertainment & Music Business. He hosts the Gavel Drop on Music Row Dealmakers. Read more on Substack.

Related: Intellectual Property Law: Is it relevant in today’s high speed digital age? (November 2017)

Related on Law on the Row

This article is general information, not legal advice. If you have a specific dispute or contract question, consult a lawyer licensed in your jurisdiction.

In 1963, two young Louisiana songwriters signed away the rights to a song that would become a 1966 hit for the Swingin’ Medallions: “Double Shot (Of My Baby’s Love).” Nearly sixty years later, co-writer Cyril Vetter used federal copyright termination to take the song back. The question that followed has big money riding on it: when a songwriter reclaims a song, does he get back only the U.S. rights, or the rights everywhere in the world?

On October 19, 2026, the U.S. Supreme Court let stand a Fifth Circuit ruling that answered “everywhere.” Here is what happened, what it does and does not settle, and what it could mean for songwriters, artists, estates and publishers on Music Row.

A quick refresher on copyright termination

The Copyright Act gives authors and their heirs a one-time chance to undo old deals. For grants signed on or after January 1, 1978, Section 203 opens a termination window that generally starts 35 years after the grant. For songs whose copyrights were secured before 1978 under a pre-1978 grant, Section 304(c) opens a window 56 years after the copyright was secured.

The process is strict. A written notice must be served at least two and no more than ten years before the effective date, and it must be recorded with the U.S. Copyright Office before that date. Works made for hire and grants made by will cannot be terminated. Derivative works made before termination, such as an existing master recording, can generally keep being used under the old deal, but new uses revert to the author or heirs.

What happened in the Vetter case

According to court records and press coverage, Vetter served his termination notice in 2019 with a 2022 effective date, then sued the publisher that had acquired the song’s original publishing company. A federal court in Louisiana ruled that Vetter and his company owned the song worldwide. On January 12, 2026, the Fifth Circuit affirmed, holding that terminations under Section 304(c), together with renewal rights under the 1909 Act, return worldwide ownership, not just U.S. rights, and that this is consistent with international treaty obligations.

Major publishers, by then holding the other side of the dispute, asked the Supreme Court to step in, arguing the ruling upended decades of industry practice. Four Justices (Sotomayor, Gorsuch, Barrett and Jackson) took no part, leaving the Court without its six-Justice quorum. Under 28 U.S.C. § 2109, when the Court cannot reach a case in the next Term, it must affirm the lower court’s judgment, with the same effect as an affirmance by an equally divided Court.

What the order does and does not settle

For Mr. Vetter, the ruling stands: he owns his share of “Double Shot” worldwide. But the Supreme Court did not decide the legal question on the merits, and an affirmance of this kind does not create nationwide precedent. The Fifth Circuit’s opinion is binding in federal courts in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi. Courts elsewhere, including the Sixth Circuit, which covers Tennessee, are not bound by it and could reach a different answer in a future case. Contract language, choice-of-law clauses and foreign courts’ views of U.S. termination may also come into play.

Why it matters on Music Row

International income is a growing share of what a song earns, from foreign performance royalties to streaming in markets around the globe. If termination brings back foreign rights too, a reclaimed catalog can be worth considerably more to a writer or estate. On the other side, publishers and catalog buyers may need to rethink how they value older songs whose termination windows are open or approaching, and they may look harder at deal terms and forum choices.

Practical steps

  • Inventory your old deals. List every publishing, co-publishing and administration agreement, with signing dates and the songs each one covers.
  • Map your termination windows. Calculate when each window opens and the earliest date a notice can be served. Missing the window can mean losing the right.
  • Look at the “for hire” question. Termination does not apply to works made for hire, so check how each agreement characterized the work.
  • Think about where you would sue. Until another appeals court or the Supreme Court weighs in, where a dispute is heard may matter.
  • Estates, coordinate early. When an author has died, a majority interest of the statutory heirs generally must act together.
  • Buyers and publishers, update diligence. Factor termination timing and possible worldwide reversion into catalog valuations and deal terms.

Thinking about getting your songs back?

Termination is one of the most valuable rights a songwriter has, and one of the easiest to lose through a missed deadline or a defective notice. If you are a writer, an heir, or a business that owns older catalog, our Nashville team is glad to review your agreements and help you plan. Contact Shrum Disney & Associates to start the conversation.

Related on Law on the Row

Related video

Barry Neil Shrum breaks down the Supreme Court’s Vetter order on the Music Row Dealmakers Gavel Drop: Breaking: 5 Justices and a Double Shot: The Supreme Court, a $1 Song & Who Gets the World Rights.

Further reading

This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, contact Shrum Disney & Associates or call 615.338.5130.

Related Video: Who Owns an AI Song?

On Music Row Dealmakers, entertainment attorney Barry Neil Shrum breaks down what songwriters actually own when they use AI. Subscribe for more.


Nashville runs on co-writes. Three writers walk into a room at 10 a.m. and walk out with a song by lunch. What they often do not walk out with is a written record of who owns what. Years later, when the song is cut, synced or sold as part of a catalog, that missing piece of paper can cost real money and real friendships.

What is a split sheet?

A split sheet is a short written agreement, usually one page, signed by everyone who contributed to a song. It records each writer’s percentage of ownership in the composition (the lyrics and music) and the information needed to register and collect royalties.

Why it matters legally

When two or more people create a song intending to merge their contributions into a single work, the result is generally a “joint work” under the U.S. Copyright Act. Without a written agreement, co-authors are typically treated as owning equal, undivided shares, regardless of who wrote more. Each co-owner can also generally grant non-exclusive licenses, subject to a duty to account to the others. A split sheet replaces those defaults with what the writers actually agreed.

A signed writing also matters later. Transfers of copyright ownership must be in a signed writing, and a clean paper trail makes publishing deals, catalog sales and registrations far smoother.

What a good split sheet includes

  • Song title (and any working titles) and the date written
  • Each writer’s legal name, professional name, address, email and signature
  • Each writer’s ownership percentage (they must add up to 100%)
  • Each writer’s performing rights organization (BMI, ASCAP, SESAC or GMR) and IPI/CAE number
  • Each writer’s publisher (or administrator) and that publisher’s share
  • Whether any samples, interpolations or pre-existing material were used
  • Whether any AI tools were used, and how (increasingly important for registration)

Common mistakes

  1. Waiting until the song is cut. Memories fade and leverage shifts. Sign it in the room.
  2. Confusing the composition with the master. A split sheet covers the song, not the recording. Producer points and master ownership need a separate agreement.
  3. Forgetting the “track guy.” If a producer contributed melody or chord structure, they may be a co-writer. Address it on day one.
  4. Not registering. The split sheet only helps if the splits are registered with your PRO and with The MLC for mechanical royalties.
  5. Handshake changes. If writers agree to change splits later, put the change in a new signed writing.

Our take

A split sheet costs nothing and takes five minutes. Litigating ownership of a hit can take years. We help songwriters, publishers and producers set up simple split-sheet templates, resolve disputed splits, and clean up catalogs before a sale. If you have a song with unclear ownership, the best time to fix it is before it earns money; the second-best time is now.

Related on Law on the Row

This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, contact Shrum Disney & Associates or call 615.338.5130.

Yesterday I had the honor of attending the announcement of the Nashville Songwriters Hall of Fame’s 2018 inductees, Ronnie Dunn, K.T. Oslin, Byron Hill, Wayne Kirkpatrick and Joe Melson.  I am so honored to serve as general counsel for this outstanding organization and serve with president Pat Alger, executive director Mark Ford, and all of the other talented and wonderful directors on the board, not to mention the fact that I get to brush elbows with these 200+ amazingly talented songwriters.  Below is the press release:

[/fusion_text][fusion_text columns=”” column_min_width=”” column_spacing=”” rule_style=”default” rule_size=”” rule_color=”” class=”” id=””]Nashville, TN August 7, 2018 – Ronnie Dunn, K.T. Oslin, Byron Hill, Wayne Kirkpatrick and Joe Melson will be inducted into the Nashville Songwriters Hall of Fame in October, according to an announcement made today by Hall of Fame member Pat Alger, chair of the organization’s board of directors.

The five new inductees will join the 208 existing members of the elite organization when they are officially inducted during the 48th Anniversary Nashville Songwriters Hall of Fame Gala on Sunday, October 28, at the Music City Center.

“This time of year, as board chair of the Nashville Songwriters Hall of Fame Foundation, I am always reminded of the broad variety and high quality of the songwriting talent we are so fortunate to be able to celebrate,” says Alger.  “The musical trends might change through the years, but for us it always comes down to great songs and legendary songwriters – the bedrock of the town that continues to be hailed as Music City.  This year’s nominees for the Nashville Songwriters Hall of Fame were inspiring and impressive as always, each one deserving recognition for the impact they made. Today it’s my great honor to welcome the Nashville Songwriters Hall of Fame class of 2018:  Byron Hill and Wayne Kirkpatrick in the songwriter category; Joe Melson in the veteran songwriter category; Ronnie Dunn as our songwriter/artist and K.T. Oslin as our veteran songwriter/ artist.”

Byron Hill’s songwriter credits include “Pickin’ Up Strangers” (Johnny Lee), “Fool Hearted Memory” (George Strait) and “Nothing On But The Radio” (Gary Allan).  Wayne Kirkpatrick’s resume is known for the Grammy-winning “Change The World” (Eric Clapton) and “Little White Church” (Little Big Town) and the Broadway musical Something Rotten!.  Joe Melson is the co-writer of the Roy Orbison hits “Only The Lonely (Know The Way I Feel),” “Crying” and “Blue Bayou.”  Ronnie Dunn popularized many of his own compositions, including the Brooks & Dunn hits “Neon Moon,” “Boot Scootin’ Boogie” and “Believe.”  K.T. Oslin recorded many of her self-penned hits, including “80s Ladies,” “Hold Me” and “Come Next Monday.”

The Nashville Songwriters Hall of Fame Gala is one of the music industry’s premier events of the year.  The evening features tributes and performances of the inductees’ songs by special guest artists.  In recent years artists such as Garth Brooks, Luke Bryan, Jimmy Buffett, Ronnie Dunn, Emmylou Harris, Alan Jackson, Tim McGraw, Thomas Rhett, Blake Shelton, Marty Stuart, Taylor Swift, Josh Turner and Trisha Yearwood have performed at or participated in the event.

Also at the event, NaSHOF will present Reba McEntire with the inaugural Career Maker Award in honor of her significant influence on the songwriting careers of Hall of Fame members.

Tickets for the Hall of Fame Gala are $250 each and benefit the nonprofit Nashville Songwriters Foundation.  Select seating is available to the public and may be purchased as available by contacting Executive Director Mark Ford athoftix@nashvillesongwritersfoundation.com or 615-460-6556.
 
About the Nashville Songwriters Hall of Fame:

Induction into the Nashville Songwriters Hall of Fame is one of the nation’s most highly prized songwriting achievements.  Since 1970, the Hall has enshrined more than 200 of the greatest writers from all genres of music ever to put words to music in Music City, including such luminaries as Bill Anderson, Bobby Braddock, Garth Brooks, Felice & Boudleaux Bryant, Johnny Cash, Don & Phil Everly, Harlan Howard, Kris Kristofferson, Loretta Lynn, Bob McDill, Bill Monroe, Willie Nelson, Roy Orbison, Dolly Parton, Dottie Rambo, Jimmie Rodgers, Fred Rose, Don Schlitz, Cindy Walker and Hank Williams.  Operated by the non-profit Nashville Songwriters Foundation, the Hall of Fame is dedicated to honoring Nashville’s rich legacy of songwriting excellence through preservation, celebration and education.  More information is available at http://www.nashvillesongwritersfoundation.com/.
 
Photo (l-r) Inductees Wayne Kirkpatrick, Byron Hill and Joe Melson; NaSHOF Executive Director Mark Ford; Inductees K. T.  Oslin and Ronnie Dunn.

Photo Credit:  Bev Moser
 
Contacts for the Nashville Songwriters Hall of Fame:

Media
Jennifer Bohler / Alliance
615 292 5804
jenny@jb-alliance.com

Executive Director
Mark Ford / NaSHOF
615 460 6556
markford@nashvillesongwritersfoundation.com

[/fusion_text][/fusion_builder_column][fusion_builder_column type=”1_3″ layout=”1_3″ spacing=”” center_content=”no” link=”” target=”_self” min_height=”” hide_on_mobile=”small-visibility,medium-visibility,large-visibility” class=”” id=”” background_color=”” background_image=”” background_position=”left top” background_repeat=”no-repeat” hover_type=”none” border_size=”0″ border_color=”” border_style=”solid” border_position=”all” padding_top=”” padding_right=”” padding_bottom=”” padding_left=”” dimension_margin=”” animation_type=”” animation_direction=”left” animation_speed=”0.3″ animation_offset=”” last=”no”][fusion_text columns=”” column_min_width=”” column_spacing=”” rule_style=”default” rule_size=”” rule_color=”” class=”” id=””]

Inductee Biographical Information
 
BYRON HILL

Winston-Salem, N.C., native Byron Hill moved to Nashville in 1978 and soon signed with ATV Music Group, where he enjoyed his first cuts with “Pickin’ Up Strangers” by Johnny Lee and George Strait’s first #1 “Fool Hearted Memory” in 1982.  Byron left ATV in 1984, but his songwriting resume continued to expand with “Nights” by Ed Bruce, “Born Country” by Alabama, “Alright Already” by Larry Stewart, “Lifestyles Of The Not So Rich And Famous” by Tracy Byrd, “High-Tech Redneck” by George Jones, “If I Was A Drinkin’ Man” by Neal McCoy, “Nothing On But The Radio” by Gary Allan and “Size Matters (Someday)” by Joe Nichols.  Other artists who have recorded Byron’s songs include Jason Aldean, Randy Travis, Keith Whitley, Rhonda Vincent, Don Williams, Trace Adkins, Toby Keith, Porter Wagoner, Brooks & Dunn, The Oak Ridge Boys, Ricky Skaggs and Reba McEntire.  To date, Byron’s songs have generated more than 700 recordings, earned 91 RIAA certified Gold and Platinum awards, 10 ASCAP awards, 34 U.S. and Canadian Top-10 chart hits and numerous hits in other global markets.
 
WAYNE KIRKPATRICK

At age 14, Wayne Kirkpatrick moved with his family to Baton Rouge, La.  After a guitar lesson at a Florida Bible camp, Wayne began spending hours after school writing songs and playing younger brother Karey’s acoustic guitar.  Both brothers eventually moved to Nashville, where Karey helped Wayne secure some of his first cuts.  Since then, Wayne has had nearly two dozen chart-topping Contemporary Christian and Pop singles, including “Every Heartbeat,” “Good For Me” and “Takes A Little Time” by Amy Grant and “Place In This World” by Michael W. Smith (the 1992 Dove Song of the Year).  In 1996, Wayne’s co-written “Change The World” by Eric Clapton was featured in the film Phenomenon and earned the 1996 Grammy for Song of the Year.  In 1999 Wayne sang, played and co-wrote eight songs on Garth Brooks’ In The Life Of Chris Gaines project, including “Lost In You” and “It Don’t Matter To The Sun.”  In 2002 he began a longtime collaboration with Little Big Town that yielded hits such as “Boondocks,” “Bring It On Home” and “Little White Church.”  In 2010, Wayne and Karey began working on the musical Something Rotten!, which opened on Broadway in 2015 and earned 10 Tony Award nominations, including Best Musical and Best Original Score.  The show launched a U.S. tour in 2017.

JOE MELSON
Joe Melson grew up in Bonham, Texas.  He began writing and singing his own songs at an early age.  He spent much of his young adult years working at Standard Oil by day then playing high-school dances and local night clubs with his Rockabilly band by night.  In 1957, Joe met and began writing with a then-unknown Roy Orbison.  In 1960, their song “Only The Lonely (Know The Way I Feel)” launched Orbison into superstardom.  The first operatic rock ballad in history, that single was inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame in 1999.  In 1961, the team created the smash “Crying.”  It became a giant hit for Orbison, was revived as a pop hit by Jay & The Americans five years later and entered the country repertoire via versions by Ronnie Milsap and Don McLean, among many others. Orbison’s single was inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame in 2002.  In 1963, the duo’s “Blue Bayou” became another hit for Orbison (and, years later, Linda Ronstadt).  Joe’s song catalgoue also includes “Blue Angel,” “Running Scared,” “Lana” and “I’m Hurtin’” (all hits for Orbison), as well as “Run Baby Run (Back Into My Arms)” by The Newbeats and the Glenn Barber singles “Unexpected Goodbye” and “I’m The Man On Susie’s Mind.”  In 2002 Joe was inducted into the Rockabilly Hall of Fame.
 
RONNIE DUNN

Ronnie Dunn was born in Texas, but Tulsa, Okla., became his hometown.  He began playing guitar and performing in Country bands when he was in his teens.  After winning the Marlboro Talent Search, Arista Records expressed interest in him.  The label teamed him with singer-songwriter Kix Brooks, and the two recorded as Brooks & Dunn from 1991-2011.  The mega-duo sold millions of records and was named CMA Vocal Duo 14 times.  The Brooks & Dunn hits “Neon Moon,” “Hard Workin’ Man,” “She Used To Be Mine,” “She’s Not The Cheatin’ Kind” and “Little Miss Honky Tonk” were all written solo by Ronnie, as was “Boot Scootin’ Boogie,” which was named ACM Song of the Year in 1992.  Ronnie was BMI’s Country Songwriter of the Year in 1996 and 1998.  Co-written Brooks & Dunn hits include songs such as “Brand New Man,” “My Next Broken Heart” and “Believe,” which was the ACM Song of the Year in 2005 and the CMA Song and Single of the Year in 2006.   In  2011, Ronnie resumed his solo career as a singer-songwriter with “Cost Of Livin’.”  Ronnie was inducted into the Oklahoma Music Hall of Fame in 2003.

K.T. OSLIN
Kay Toinette Oslin was born in Crossett, Arkansas.  After her father died, she moved with her mother to Houston, where she later attended college as a drama major.  In 1966, she joined the road company of Hello Dolly!.  When the musical returned to Broadway, K.T. remained in the cast.  During the next two decades, she appeared as a chorus girl in musicals such as Promises, Promises and West Side Story.  She also sang commercial jingles around New York and began writing songs.  By 1981, she was signed to Elektra Records and released two singles with modest success.  She also had songs recorded by Gail Davies, The Judds and Dottie West.  By 1987, K.T. had moved to Nashville and signed with RCA Nashville.  She scored big with her self-penned “80s Ladies,” which was named 1988 CMA Song of the Year, making her the first female writer to win the award.  That album also launched the singles “Do Ya” and “I’ll Always Come Back.”  Her second album generated five singles, including “Money,” “Hey Bobby,” “This Woman,” “Didn’t Expect It To Go Down This Way” and “Hold Me,” which earned the 1988 Grammy for Best Country Song.  K.T.’s third album generated the hits “Come Next Monday” and “Mary And Willie.”  She was named 1988, 1989 and 1991 SESAC Songwriter of the Year.  K.T. is a 2014 inductee into the Texas Heritage Songwriters Hall of Fame.

                                   ###

 

Shrum & Associates’ very own namesake, Barry Neil Shrum, Esquire, was recently appointed to serve as general counsel for the Nashville Songwriters’ Hall of Fame, and to serve as a non-voting member of its Board of Directors.  The Nashville Songwriters Hall of Fame Foundation (NaSHOF) is a non-profit organization dedicated to honoring and preserving the songwriting legacy that is uniquely associated with the Nashville music community. Its purpose is to educate, celebrate and archive the achievements and contributions made by members of the Nashville Songwriters Hall of Fame to the world. 

Induction into the Nashville Songwriters Hall of Fame (NaSHOF) is one of the nation’s most highly prized songwriting honors. Since 1970, nearly 200 of Music City’s top tunesmiths from all genres of music have been enshrined by the non-profit organization, which honors Nashville’s rich legacy of songwriting excellence through preservation, celebration and education. In 2013, NaSHOF realized a long-held dream with the opening of its Hall of Fame Gallery, located in downtown Nashville on the first floor of the Music City Center (201Image result for nashville songwriters hall of fame 5th Avenue South).

NaSHOF chairman of the Board, Patrick (“Pat”) J. Alger III (2010 NaHOF inductee), described Mr. Shrum as a perfect fit:

The Board of the Nashville Songwriters Foundation has patiently and cautiously been searching for a replacement for our longtime legal counsel [David Maddox] who recently retired. As Chairman and the de facto representative that bears the responsibility for our actions and decisions it is especially important to me to find the right candidate. I believe we got very fortunate when Barry Shrum expressed interest in filling that vacancy. He has the right combination of knowledge, experience and personality to fit the bill precisely! We welcome him enthusiastically to our team.

Mr. Shrum expressed equal admiration for his new chairman and for the organization:

I was honored when Mr. Alger approached me about the position.  Pat is in the pantheon of songwriting gods here in Nashville and the writer of one of my favorite Garth Brooks’ songs, Unanswered Prayers.  I am looking forward to serving under his considered and kind leadership.  I can’t think of anything I would rather be remembered for more so than protecting and honoring the rights of such great songwriters like Pat Alger and the other 200 or so inductees.

Mark Ford, Executive Director of the NaSHOF, expressed excitement about the appointment:

I’m excited that Barry has joined the board of the Nashville Songwriters Hall of Fame.  His knowledge of copyrights and their creators, combined with his years of experience in the music industry, are a great fit for our organization.  He’s a pleasure to be around, a delight to work with and someone who will definitely stand shoulder-to-shoulder with us as we strive to honor Nashville’s rich legacy of songwriting excellence.

NaSHOF is currently producing a series of critically-acclaimed weekly television series called The Songwriters which features engaging conversations with NaSHOF inductees, including Gary Burr, Bill Anderson, Steve Cropper, Ray Stevens and many others.  The inaugural season is hosted by NaHOF Board member, Ken Paulson, and is produced at MTSU’s College of Media and Entertainment.  The shows airs three times weekly on Nashville Public Television as well in 10 other markets across the country.

Mr. Shrum accepted the position and took on the role in December of 2017.

[/fusion_text][/fusion_builder_column][/fusion_builder_row][/fusion_builder_container]

 

The first of the month (August 2016), the Department of Justice issued a summary of findings with regard to two court orders that govern the operation of two of the U.S. performing rights organizations (the “PRO’s”), ASCAP and BMI.  If it stands, the decision will also affect the third PRO, SESAC.

Songwriters and music publishers around the country were horrified with the DOJ findings, as were the PRO’s, with many songwriters claiming that they would now have to refrain from co-writing with songwriters belonging to one of the sister PRO’s.  This article will examine the logic of the reaction by the music community.  Is the proverbial sky falling, or will this event pass into obscurity and irrelevance?  We’ll sort out what all this means in this article.

As an aside, if you were not fortunate enough to tune into last night’s episode of my friends Heino and Scott with The Music Row Show on WSM 650, go to their website and check out the archives, as much of the information we share here was talked about in that radio program.  My appearance and conversation with The Music Row Show made me realize just how confused many songwriters will be about all of this legal maneuvering.  

Background

Before we look at the court orders, referred to as “Consent Decrees,” a little historical background will be helpful.  As I said, there are primarily three PRO’s, ASCAP, SESAC and BMI, and they were created in that order.   The two largest US PRO’s, ASCAP and BMI, make up the majority of the industry.  SESAC, by most accounts, has between 10-20% market share (although it is growing exponentially).

This is because ASCAP and BMI were both created out of controversy and strife and that highly competitive environmental produced some robust and resilient entities.  ASCAP arouse out of the Tin Pan Alley days.  Several of the key songwriters, IRVING BERLIN, VICTOR HERBERT and JOHN PHILLIPS SOUSA, began to see their songs being performed in restaurants, hotel lobbies and other venues, and they realized that they were not receiving royalties from these performances, a right that was first granted in 1897 and then incorporated directly into the 1909 Act.  These famous writers banded together to form the first coalition of songwriters and publisher, the American Society of Authors, Composers and Publishers.

Their efforts may have been received well in the music community, but the entities that used the music did not share that enthusiasm.  Certain NYC restaurant and hotel magnets, namely Shanely and Vanderbilt, questioned whether they were required to pay the composer for performance of a song in their establishments, even though they charged no admission for those performances.  The music, they maintained, was just a side show and not the main focus of what their customers were paying for.

The case, Herbert et al. v. Shanley et al. went all the way to the Supreme Court.  Writing for the majority, Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes ruled in favor of ASCAP and songwriters, saying:

Music is part of the total for which the public pays and the fact that the price of the whole is attributable to a particular item which those present are expected to order is not important.  It is true that music is not the sole object, but neither is the food, which probably could be got cheaper elsewhere.

As a result, ASCAP had the stamp of approval from the highest court in the land.  They started an aggressive campaign to acquire licenses from venues where performances of music occurred, including broadcasters like television and radio stations. 

BMI arose as a direct result of ASCAP’s aggressive licensing activities.  From 1931-1939, ASCAP increased its royalty rates to radio and television stations over 400%, to the point where a group of broadcasters decided to get together and form Broadcast Musicians Incorporated in 1939.  They started signing their own composers and begin licensing non-ASCAP works for their catalog.  After a few years, most radio and television stations stopped using ASCAP music and would only use BMI-licensed music.

BMI and ASCAP have been adversaries ever since.  ASCAP, of course, had the upper hand, since they were first to market and arose out of the Tin Pan Alley environment.  ASCAP did not take kindly to being shut out of the lucrative broadcast market and the two organizations began a decades long fight for the music users.  This conflict ultimately caught the attention of the DOJ, who sued each entity under the Sherman Act (anti-trust) to address their comparative market power and balance the weight of power.  The result of the DOJ’s involvement were the consent decrees that, to this day, govern how terrestrial radio (Either AM/FM) digital rebroadcasts, and/or venues such as bars and arenas, license the performance of compositions.

SESAC, a European PRO at first licensing mostly classical, slipped into the U.S. in 1939 amidst all of this sibling rivalry and began licensing in the U.S., but as a private entity as opposed to operating as a non-profit like ASCAP and BMI.  They are not subject to any consent decrees and to this day remain under the radar, although the DOJ periodically audits them as well.

The ASCAP/BMI consent decrees defining what the PRO’s can and cannot not do – most notably, it requires them to issue “blanket licenses” to certain users.  These have been amended in 2003 and 1994 respectively.  The decrees also require that both entities offer licenses are similar terms and to similar clientele.  Importantly, for this discussion, the consent decree require that the PRO’s license to a user like Pandora one a request for license is made, regardless of whether a rate has been negotiated.  If the PRO’s and the user cannot agree on a rate, it is then presented to the “rate court” set up by the consent decree to decide.  The catch is that while all of this legal wrangling is going on, services like Pandora can continue performing the music.

The Recent DOJ Ruling

The gravamen of this issue happened in 2013 when several large music publishers, SONY ATV, EMI and Universal, among others, withdrew their “new media” licensing rights from ASCAP and BMI, leaving them to collect only their terrestrial right (read broadcasted radio or television).  They did this for a couple of reasons:  first, the consent decree do not allow the PRO’s to negotiate a market rate with digital streaming services; so, secondly, they did it in order to negotiate better deals directly with Pandora.  In 2013, Pandora negotiated a favorable percentage rate with Sony and Universal based on their gross revenues.

With their hands tied and major publishers going direct to digital stream services, ASCAP and BMI had no choice.  Streaming revenues have been increasing for years, and without these major players bringing in revenue, their revenues were decreasing.  So, in short, ASCAP and BMI went back to the DOJ seeking clarification with regard to the consent decrees with regard to operation and effectiveness.  Among other things, ASCAP/BMI ask that the decrees be modified to allow publishers/songwriters to “partially withdraw” their works.  This prompted a new review of the Consent Decrees by the Department of Justice that begin in 2014.  The DOJ released its findings on August 4, 2016 of this month.

The DOJ said that the ASCAP consent decrees doesn’t allow a publisher to withdraw partial shares.  It stated that consent decrees require a PRO “license to perform all the works in [fusion_builder_container hundred_percent=”yes” overflow=”visible”][fusion_builder_row][fusion_builder_column type=”1_1″ background_position=”left top” background_color=”” border_size=”” border_color=”” border_style=”solid” spacing=”yes” background_image=”” background_repeat=”no-repeat” padding=”” margin_top=”0px” margin_bottom=”0px” class=”” id=”” animation_type=”” animation_speed=”0.3″ animation_direction=”left” hide_on_mobile=”no” center_content=”no” min_height=”none”][its] repertory…” That meant, according to the DOJ, that it could not “rewrite the decree” to let publishers pick and choose how works are licensed and allow fractional shares.  This has great impact on the existing deals already negotiated with Pandora.  Specifically, the DOJ said:

The licensing of works through ASCAP is offered to publishers on a take-it-or-leave-it basis.

Specifically, the DOJ ruled:

1)  That the consent decrees would not be modified or abolished

2)  That the consent decrees to DO NOT allow “fractional” licenses that convey only fractional shares and required additional (read other PRO) to perform the works, i.e, the DOJ interpreted the consent decrees to require “full-work” licensing.

This new and dramatically different interpretation requires the PRO’s to convey licenses to radio, television, bars and digital music services giving them the right to public perform “100%” of their repertoires without the risk of adverse infringement.  This new “full-work licensing” principal applies even if ASCAP or BMI only represent a small fraction of a song’s copyright, which is almost always the case.  The problem, of course, is that ASCAP and BMI do not generally have the legal right to convey 100%!

Ironically, the DOJ findings state that “the current status quo system [used by the PRO’s]. . . has served the industry well for decades and should remain intact.”   This is confusing, since historically the PRO’s have licensed fractional shares, contrary to the DOJ’s findings.  A single song most often is written by multiple songwriters and those songwriters are generally affiliated with different performance rights organizations and only own a fractional interest in that song.  When a song such as All-American Girl, is written by Carrie Underwood, whose performance is licensed by BMI, with two other ASCAP songwriters, traditionally BMI would license 33.33% of the song and ASCAP would license the other 66.66%.  Now, according to the DOJ, either BMI and or ASCAP would have to license 100% of the song and report and pay the royalties for the other songwriters to the other PRO.  Imagine how these historic competitors view that prospect!

Herein lies a big part of this current problem.  If we look to copyright law, as we must, the answers may be clearer.  Under section 201(a), the author of song is the owner of the song.  But as all songwriters in Nashville are prone to collaborate, we have to factor in a second author/owner.  When that happens, the copyright law treats each owner as a tenant-in-common, just like two spouses who jointly own a house.  In other word, each one owns 100%.  So what does that mean?

That means that “[e]ach co-owner may thus grant a nonexclusive license to use the entire work without the consent of other co-owners, provided that the licensor accounts for and pays over to his or her co-owners their pro-rata shares of the proceeds.” United States Copyright Office, Views of the United States Copyright Office Concerning PRO Licensing of Jointly Owned Works (2016).  Of course, the songwriters can alter this default situation through signing a collaboration agreement, but no one ever does because that would “harsh the songwriting vibe.”

Furthermore, in a joint author situation, either author of the work may enforce the right to exclude others from using the work.  So, each author of a joint work “has the independent right to use or license the copyright subject only to a duty to account for any profits he earns from the licensing or use of the copyright.” Ashton-Tate Corp., 916 F.2d at 522 (9th Cir.1990). Accordingly, a joint copyright owner may not exclude other joint owners or persons who have a license from another joint owner. 

But there is another part of this analysis that can’t be ignored, and that is the doctrine of indivisibility.  Under the prior, 1909 Copyright Act, the author(s) could NOT divide the copyright, meaning that if the copyright was licensed, the entire copyright had to be licensed, not just one of the exclusive rights.  So, I would not be able to issue a print license apart from a license to perform the work.  The 1976 Act eliminated this doctrine and effectively made the copyright divisible.  Specifically, Section 201(d)(1) of the Act states that the ownership of a copyright may be transferred in whole or in part by any means of conveyance or by operation of law.  Further, the following section 201(d)(2) specifies that this principle of divisibility applied to each of the exclusive rights – print, adaptation, distribution, reproduction and performance – which could be divided, transferred and owned separately.

Now, for the first time, an author could license only the performance rights.  But more specifically, the author could license only a portion of his/her performance rights.  So, you see, the idea of transferring fractional shares of a copyright, or one of the exclusive rights of a copyright, is actually built into the copyright act.  This is something the DOJ ruling completely ignored in its analysis when it interpreted the Consent Decrees to require the PRO’s to offer 100% licensing of their catalog. 

The DOJ, however, was focused primarily on the user of the music, completely ignoring the creators.  For the user, the DOJ felt it was egregious to have to go to all three PRO’s to get a license to perform one work.  To be fair, the PRO’s have tiptoed gingerly around this issue for years.  A license from one songwriter/publisher to perform a work should, in theory, be sufficient.  That is, after all, the meaning of a non-exclusive license.  The industry has avoided the user aspect of partial rights grants for years, requiring each user to obtain a “blanket license” from all three PRO’s in order to perform each PRO’s catalog (and consequently, glossing over the fact that a license to perform one individual work from the owner of copyright would suffice to perform the work).  In this way, each PRO could distribute the royalties collected on the benefit of their members to each one respectively according to their own algorithms. 

That process may change if the DOJ’s consent decree remains in effect.  Each PRO would have to agree who collects for a particular license, and then credit the other with their share.  This would require each one to adjust their rates accordingly and account to and pay some of the royalties received to the other PRO’s.  While it can’t be stated definitively, one just feels that this process will somehow negatively impact the songwriters and publishers, and not the PRO’s or the venues.

Most people in the industry predict that application of this “full-work” licensing approach will throw the music industry in complete and utter chaos – and they’re probably correct.  But, as I said earlier, all hope is not yet lost.  First, the DOJ gave ASCAP and BMI one year to get their act together and start operating on the 100% licensing principle they outlined.   Second, for perhaps the first time in history, ASCAP and BMI are bedfellows (you know what they say of politics) in that they have agreed to a course of reaction:  BMI is appealing the DOJ’s ruling while ASCAP is lobbying Congress for relief.   ASCAP and BMI both announced that they would join forces to fight this common foe.

The president of BMI, Michael O’Neill, was quoted in the Tennessean in response:

The DOJ’s interpretation of our consent decree serves no one, not the marketplace, the music publishers, the music users, and most importantly, not our songwriters and composers who now have the government weighing in on their creative and financial decisions.  Unlike the DOJ, we believe that our consent decree permits fractional licensing, a practice that encourages competition in our industry and fosters creativity and collaboration among music creators, a factor the DOJ completely dismissed.

For her part, CEO of ASCAP, Elizabeth Matthews stated that:

The DOJ decision puts the U.S. completely out of step with the entire global music marketplace, denies American music creators their rights, and potentially disrupts the flow of music without any benefit to the public.  That is why ASCAP will work with our allies in Congress, BMI and leaders within the music industry to explore legislative solutions to challenge the DOJ’s 100 percent licensing decision and enact the modifications that will protect songwriters, composers and the music we all love.

Most people outside the industry will have no idea how significant it is that both of this PRO’s are cooperating with each other on this issue.  ASCAP’s and BMI’s joint efforts may serve to put pressure on Congress to address an aging Copyright Act and implement some of the recommendations made by the Copyright Office in 2015, namely, the creation of a mega “Music Rights Organization” or MRO that, among other things, licenses all exclusive rights of the copyright owner, including both performance and mechanical rights.  The Copyright Office also recommended an elimination of the Consent Decrees.  U.S. Rep. Bob Goodlatte, R-Virginia, who is chairman of the House Judiciary Committee, is expected to recommend changes to the Copyright Act that could be taken up on the 2017 Congress.

In the midst of all of this activity, SESAC is again quietly biding their time, acquiring Harry Fox (mechanical rights) and Rumblefish (a “record label” including digital performance rights) in preparation for becoming perhaps the first effective “MRO.”

No one truly knows the ultimate outcome of all of this but one thing is certain:  the history of performance rights organizations in America continues to evolve.  The copyright law is very complex and have evolved over the years since its passage in 1976.  That law took almost half a century to pass and there is no reason to believe that a new revision wouldn’t take just as long given the multiple competing and often conflicting interests of various stakeholders.  But patience is not the songwriter’s only recourse here:  write your elected representative in Washington and plead your case, as free speech is the only right that will make a difference in this fight.

 

[/fusion_builder_column][/fusion_builder_row][/fusion_builder_container]

Innovation

You cannot discover new oceans unless you have the courage to lose sight of the shore.

As it does every year, this new year marks a new beginning. I plan to continue my Twitter series entitled #creativity, so if you don’t already, follow me there @bshrum, or on any of the social networking platforms. However, I wanted to announce the series here and say a few words on the topic.

There is a trend in modern thinking to discount the significance, and even the possibility, of original thought. The movement is similar to the quo
te from Proverbs that there is “nothing new under the sun.” In other words, people are basically saying that an original idea is not possible, since every idea has already been expressed. This idea stems from the corresponding line of thinking that all ideas should be free. If this is true, there is not room for creativity, thought, inspiration, invention and innovation. All such “new” ideas would, in fact, be in the zeitgeist already.

Obviously, I do not agree with this line of thought. I come from a family of creative thinkers and I know from experience that new thought can, and is, generated every day. Our own experience in society falsifies the notion that there is nothing new under the sun, as we see in American history a lineage of great, original thinkers and invention. The light bulb, the automobile, electricity, the assembly line, the telephone etc. etc. All of these innovations are based on sparks of creativity. As American author Jonah Lehrer says,

“Creativity is a spark. It can be excruciating when we’re rubbing two rocks together and getting nothing. And it can be intensely satisfying when the flame catches and a new idea sweeps around the world.”

This is a wonderful insight. It is most certainly difficult in most instances to spontaneously generate truly unique thoughts. There is a propensity in the Nashville songwriting community to attempt to “force” this spark by scheduling co-writing sessions with other like-minded songwriters. This sometime results in frequent complaints about the songs being produced and performed in Nashville, i.e., that they are “all alike.” What people are really saying is that many of the songs are not creative. So, while these co-writing sessions may occasionally produce some innovative ideas, it seems that more frequently the practice is a lot like “rubbing two rocks together” in an effort to create the spark, but actually producing a lot of similar songs.

So, the question is can a person actually do anything to foster the generation of new and creative ideas, or are well all destined to the world where there is “nothing new under the sun”? Research shows that there are certain practices which help the spontaneous generation of fresh and new ideas. I’ll share three of them:

The Inner Child

When we think of creativity, we can’t help but reminisce about the days when we were children. A child has not inhibitions or preconceived notions. To a young child, every experience is new and original. The child cannot help but want to paint, sculpt, draw, write, read and see the world in a new light.

It is that “inner child” that can help the creator generate new ideas. Think about this: why is that many great artists, no matter what the craft, often turn to substance use and abuse in times when they want to create? The reason is, of course, that using a mind altering vehicle often lowers inhibitions and “lowers our guard.” No, I’m not saying go out and tie on one in order to create your next great novel. What I am saying is that if you want to create new ideas, you have to see things from the perspective of a child. Stand on your head. Do somersaults. Perform some of your favorite childhood activities. Get in touch with you inner child and your creative juices will be stimulated.

Brainstorm

Another way to get in touch in with your inner child is to just begin writing down any idea that pops in your head, without leaving any room for judging or evaluating the validity of those ideas. This process often puts you in touch with your subconscious thoughts that are frequently suppressed by our conscious mind, where all of our rules and safeguards exist. Original thinkers often talk about thinking all the times. They have very fluent and free flowing thoughts, producing a stream of ideas that are different and sometimes unusual to the less creative observer. But this is how they derive the practical and innovative ideas. Often times, the creative thinker will spend a lot of time “incubating” ideas. As the old expression goes, they “put in their pipe and smoke it.” They percolate the idea in their head until suddenly there is a moment of “eureka” and the idea comes out fully developed. This is the moment that some people feel they are being touched by inspiration, or being guided by their “muse.” The jury may still be out on that, but in reality the key for the creator is knowing how to find these moments of illumination and capture them, regardless of from where you believe they come.

The expression “a writer writes” reflects this concept. If you look at the journals of any great thinker – Thomas Jefferson, Leonardo da Vinci, etc. – you will find scores of ideas that they did not develop. These great thinkers of the world captured their thoughts frequently. In our age of modernity, we have technologies that can assist in that tasks, but we must not lose sight of the important of writing things down as they occur. Keep a journal.

Craft

To the last point, some people believe that creativity is not a trait we inherit, but rather is a skill that is developed. That may just be something the non-creative people say, but the fact of the matter is that you CAN learn skills associated with the arts. A person can be taught to sculpt, paint, write songs or novel, etc. If Einstein had not known the “skills” of math, he would not have been able to capture his unique equation, E=mc2. His flash of insight may very well have faded into the moment, thereby changing the course of human history as we know it. My point is this: new, original and creative ideas must be captured and crafted in order to be innovative.

Once you have mastered the art of getting in touch with your inner child, brainstormed a flurry of ideas, and had your “eureka” moment of insight, you must have developed the skills necessary to capture it and put it down on paper. The art of “clothing,” or expressing the idea is a craft that must be honed and developed in order to achieve success, no matter what your area of creativity.

So, hopefully these musings of a lawyer on the subject of creativity inspire you to go out and create. Help me in my quest to stamp out this new trend in thinking that there are no new ideas. Go create some!

Since taking over Mary Beth Peters as Register of Copyrights in 2011, Maria Pallante has been listening and responding to the concerns of a number of her constituents, particularly those in the music industry, and it most certainly shows. In the last few months, several pieces of Maria_Pallantework product have been delivered by the Copyright Office and/or Congress that have significant impact on the music industry and, in particular, those of my readers who practice the craft of songwriting. If you are a songwriter, you should pay particular attentions to two of these things specifically. The first is the Copyright Office’s report, released in February 2015, titled Copyright in the Music Marketplace. The second, more directly aimed on the songwriting community, is the Songwriter’s Equity Act reintroduced to Congress in this term.

The Copyright in the Music Marketplace Report.

Anyone who works in the music or entertainment industry should take the time to read the full report, available here. The report begins in the Preface by pointing out that “both music creators and innovators that support them are increasingly doing business in legal quicksand” (Emphasis added). This “legal quicksand” that the Copyright Office references refers to licensing as it relates to both sound recordings and musical works, and the disparities that have developed over the past decade or so as a result of various amendments to the 1976 Copyright Act. For example, with regard to performance royalties for musical compositions, ASCAP and BMI have operated under consent decrees issued by the Federal Courts for years. In addition, the rate courts establish the rates that must be paid for public performance under what is referred to as a “fair market value” analysis in which the court attempts to determine the price that a willing buyer and willing seller would agree to in an arm’s length transaction. The court also gives substantial weight to antitrust concerns in this regard. For the more astute readers, you may be wondering about SESAC. SESAC generally operates as if it is subject to the consent decrees, even though technically it was not a party to them. BMI and ASCAP frequently call attention to the fact that there is disparate treatment as to SESAC. The process of setting rates for the performance rights organizations in the rate courts can be lengthy and complicated, leaving music publishers and songwriters complaining that there should be a more efficient way to set the rates.

As for mechanical royalties for reproduction of musical compositions in sound recordings, the Copyright Royalty Board (“CRB”) establishes those rates. For this purpose, the CRB operates pursuant to the compulsory licensing guidelines in Section 115 of the Copyright Act, using the four‐factor, public policy‐oriented standard in section 801(b)(1). Not complicated at all right?

That brings us to Section 116(6) of the Copyright Act, which provides royalties to sound recording authors for digital transmissions of their works. The rates for the digital performance of sound recordings is proscribed in Section 114 using dramatically different standards, depending on the type of use. This the reason royalties received from Spotify look so much different than royalties received from Sirius or terrestrial performances. Older services such as Sirius XM, the only remaining satellite service, and Music Choice or Muzak, the only remaining subscription services, are governed by the same four‐factor standard as mechanical reproductions of musical works subject to compulsory licensing under section 115 as regards royalties. According to SiriusXM’s own website, the “U.S. Music Royalty Fee” for 2015 was 13.9% of the subscription fee charged for a particular service. That fee is placed into a fund that is used to pay royalties. Meanwhile, royalty rates for Internet radio services and newer noninteractive subscription services, and for all ephemeral recordings under Section 112 regardless of the type of service, are established under the so‐called “willing buyer/willing seller” standard, which many believe yields more market‐oriented rates than those established under section 801(b)(1).

So what about Spotify, you may ask? Spotify is, by far, the largest interactive streaming service available in the marketplace, and in many ways sets the tone for what a “willing buyer” is willing to pay. According to its response to the Copyright Office’s Notice of Inquiry, it pays out “70% of all money it receives to rightsholders.” But those songwriters who have received paltry royalty checks from Spotify revenue might question the accuracy of that statement, wondering why they don’t see more. That is because Spotify doesn’t pay on a “per song stream” model, as royalties get calculated when it comes to mechanical uses. Rather, they set aside the royalties and the total royalty pie is split among all rights holders based on the percentage of total Spotify streams their songs garner. But according to a New York Times article, the company does, in fact, calculate the per rate royalties, estimating that the average song generates between $0.006 and $0.0084 per stream in royalties. That is why, to songwriter in particular, this may seem like a pittance. That’s why Taylor Swift recently announced that her new album would not be available via Spotify. But Spotify’s counters these objections, producing data that it says illustrates that the numbers really do add up for big artists such as Swift. The company reports that the most-streamed album on the service each month typically generates more than $400,000 in royalties.

Finally, with regard to performance royalties, musical composition copyright owners enjoy performance royalties froRoyaltiesm terrestrial radio while the owners of sound recording copyrights do not. The radio industry has successfully convinced Congress on numerous occasions that it operates on a “quid pro quo” basis with the record industry so that there is no need for royalty payments. After all, without the marketing that radio provides by playing the records, there would be no hit records. This may seem like an antiquated loophole in the system, because it is. There is no reason why the owners of the sound recordings should not be compensated for performance over terrestrial radio, just as music publishers and songwriters are. This loophole needs to be closed to eliminate that obvious inequity.
So, as you can see, the rate setting standards under these various statutory licenses and consent decrees differ greatly, based on what rights are implicated and the use at issue. But even for arguably similar services, such as Spotify and SiriusXM, the structure produces inconsistent results and the royalties that are paid vary widely.
In addition to the disparity in setting royalty rates in the music industry, the report called attention to the fact that there is a general lack of transparency in regard to royalty streams and ownership. For the songwriter, the concern has always been that there is money being generated from the copyright that is not finding its way into royalty check. Now, with all of these disparate royalty streams being generated from new digital sources, particularly those involving direct deals between record companies and digital users, the songwriter legitimately feel as if those revenues are not being shared. For example, the labels ostensibly negotiated an 18% stake in Spotify, which is probably the real reason they love the service so much.

All of these concerns, among others, led the Copyright Office to articulate four guiding principles derived from their discussions with “stakeholder” during their research in regard to which it says it “appreciates and agrees.” The four principles are as follows:

  1. Music creators should be fairly compensated for their contributions;
  2. The licensing process should be more efficient;
  3. Market participants should have access to authoritative data to identify and license sound recording and musical works; and
  4. Usage and payment information should be transparent and accessible to rights owners.

However, the Office acknowledged that there was no consensus on how to achieve these goals, and in the end, developed some additional principles it believed should govern any future reform of Copyright Law:

  1. Government licensing processes should aspire to treat like uses of music alike;
  2. Government supervision should enable voluntary transactions while still supporting collective solutions;
  3. Rate setting and enforcement of antitrust laws should be separately managed and addressed; and
  4. A single, market‐oriented rate setting standard should apply to all music uses under statutory licensing.

If these principles are implemented, it would be dramatic changes in the way royalties are paid, collected and distributed. The Copyright Office was not kind to the compulsory licenses provisions under Section 115 of the Copyright Act, known to many as the “statutory royalty” provisions, proposing that we “sunset” these as they expire. The existing structures under Sections 112 and 114, on the other hand, it felt worked fairly well. There are various implications for organizations such as Harry Fox and others if these changes were to occur.

Overall, however, the report was fairly balanced, and songwriters should receive more favorable treatment from Congress if it follows these principles. It remains to be seen what Congress will do with the research developed by the Copyright Office in this report. That leads us to the next topic of discussion, and that is the Songwriter’s Equity Act, introduced in March.

Songwriter’s Equity Act

This Bill was originally introduced in February 2014, but died in committee. Now, it has been reintroduced by a bipartisan coalition to both houses of Congress and, with strong Republ5237697662_f8e465b716ican support and control, there is much more optimism. The Bill, introduced by Congressman Doug Collins (R-Ga), seeks to amend Section 114 and 115 of the Copyright Act to implement some of the suggestions proposed by the Copyright Office’s report. Orrin Hatch (R-Utah), a senior senator and member of the critical Judiciary Committee, co-sponsored the legislation and has frequently been an advocate for songwriters. For one thing, it would allow the royalty courts to adapt the “fair market rate” standards when setting mechanical license rates under Section 115, and allow them to consider royalties paid to recording artist when setting rates for songwriters under Section 114. Most people believe that this would be a more profitable structure for songwriters and music publishers.

When testifying in front of Congress in regard to last year’s identical legislation, National Music Publishers Assn. president David Israelite said that

[fusion_builder_container hundred_percent=”yes” overflow=”visible”][fusion_builder_row][fusion_builder_column type=”1_1″ background_position=”left top” background_color=”” border_size=”” border_color=”” border_style=”solid” spacing=”yes” background_image=”” background_repeat=”no-repeat” padding=”” margin_top=”0px” margin_bottom=”0px” class=”” id=”” animation_type=”” animation_speed=”0.3″ animation_direction=”left” hide_on_mobile=”no” center_content=”no” min_height=”none”][t]hree-quarters of a songwriter’s income is regulated by the federal government. While most property rights are valued in a free market, songwriters have suffered under a system that devalues their work and takes away their most basic property rights.”

Israelite applauded the legislatures for standing up for songwriters.

As the Copyright Office report on music licensing discussed above recommends, if songwriters’ royalties must be regulated by government, then they should at least be based on fair market value. Collins told the Tennessean that tell songwriters and publishers that “they’ll have a friend [in me] who’s going to fight for this bill.” The bill has support from both sides of the aisle, including not only Tennessee Senators Lamar Alexander and Bob Corker, but U.S. Rep. Jim Cooper and U.S. Rep. Marsha Blackburn, R-Brentwood.

In conclusion, I think it’s about time Congress considered the equitable situation of the songwriter, the lowly work horse of the music industry.  NSAI has been saying for years that “it all begins with a song,” a phrase that was quoted in the Copyright Report, by the way, and that is, in fact, where it all begins.  But over the past decade, the significance of the songwriter has diminished and the loss revenues from record sales created by illegal downloading made it impossible for most to practice this traditional craft.  These legislative efforts seek to remedy some of that loss.

[/fusion_builder_column][/fusion_builder_row][/fusion_builder_container]